Mid-year reading report: The Thief, St Kilda Blues, Hanging Devils, In the Morning I’ll Be Gone

Hanging-Devils-Jacket1My reading has been dominated of late by the need to get through a lot of pulp books and material I need to be across for several upcoming literary festival appearances (all of which I’ll also be discussing here in the coming weeks). Between all this, however, I have managed to get through a few books purely for pleasures and I thought it was about time I shared my thoughts on these.

First up is He Jiahong’s Hanging Devils: Hong Jun Investigates. I lamented on this site some time ago about the seeming absence of genuine contemporary crime fiction set in China, written by someone living there. Well, Hanging Devils is just that. According to the back cover blurb, the author is one of China’s foremost authorities on criminal justice, a professor of law at People’s University of Beijing and the author of several best selling crime novels including four featuring the character of Hong Ju.

Hanging Devils (also the slang term given to overhanging tree branches that can fall without warning, potential killing anyone unfortunate to be underneath them) is set in the mid-nineties. China is in the throws of liberalisation, but the gap between what was and what will be is still huge. Hong Ju is a US trained Chinese lawyer, recently returned from Chicago where he practiced law. He now works as an investigating lawyer for hire. His client is a shady property developer, one of China’s emerging class of local entrepreneurs. He wants Hong Ju to look into the case of his brother, currently doing hard time for the rape and murder of a woman on a collective farm in China’s frozen northwest province of Harbin.

It seems like a relatively straightforward case. Hong Ju travels to Harbin and almost immediately unearths inconsistences and problems with the police investigation into the woman’s murder and subsequent trial of the accused. He tracks down the murdered woman’s father, who he believes has information that will help exonerate his client. But before Hong Ju can interview him in detail, the father kills himself. Meanwhile, Hong Ju’s activities are rubbing up the local Harbin police and political authorities the wrong way. Hong Ju may be a “big shot Beijing lawyer”, but this is not Chicao and things are not as they seem.

The overall plot of Hanging Devils is good and there is some fascinating period detail of China in the nineties. But the book does drag a little, particularly the copious explanations of China’s legal system and the procedures involved in police investigation. Nonetheless, kudos to Penguin for being brave enough to release this book for an English language market.

9781742537788St Kida Blues is two-time Ned Kelly award winner Geoffrey McGeavchin’s third book to feature the character of Charlie Berlin, former allied bomber pilot and Melbourne policeman. It is 1967, roughly a decade since the events of the last book, Blackwattle Creek (which I reviewed here). Melbourne is changing, the swinging sixties are here and the city is full of sex, drugs and rock and roll. Berlin on the other hand, has not changed in the slightest. Now in his forties, he’s working for the fraud squad. His kids have grown up and left home (the son is in the army in Vietnam, his daughter is living on kibbutz in Israel).

Enter Mike Roberts, nearly beaten to death by criminals in Berlin’s last book, now a flash cop with a barely legal girlfriend and a sports car that is far too expensive for his police salary. Roberts comes as an emissary from the powers that be, who want Berlin to look into the disappearance of the daughter of one of the state’s prominent businessmen, a horribly scarred migrant German called Gerhardt Schiener. The daughter is just one of many young girls who were last seen at nightclubs in the CBD,one of whom has just turned up naked and dead. It’s obviously the work of a serial killer, whose early life is told in series of very well written flash backs interspersed through the first half of the book.

I am never quite sure what to think about McGeachin’s books. Like Blackwattle Creek, I enjoyed this book. The man can write and he handles the period detail of late sixties Melbourne superbly. I particularly enjoyed his descriptions of the sleazy male denizens of the city’s club culture and the photographers who make a living by taking picture for local rock and roll mags. The exception is his attempt to depict St Kilda as a sort of Antipodean version of Polanski’s Chinatown, which doesn’t quite come off:

Roberts shook his head. “You know how it is, Charlie, it’s St Kilda. A naked fifteen-year-old-girl isn’ going to attract too much attention at three or four in the morning, not around this area.”

I think what I don’t like about these books is the character of Berlin. He’s always been a rather dour, conservative individual. But amid Melbourne’s Summer of Love, he comes across as particularly moralistic and preachy, forever tut tutting about drug use and the fact that skirts are getting shorter. It may work for others but it turned me off.

GoneIt is a generally reliable rule of thumb that book series get worse as they go on. Not so in the case of In the Morning I’ll Be Gone, the third book by Adrian McKinty to feature Sean Duffy, a Catholic cop in a Protestant dominated force,

Belfast, September 1983. Duffy has been demoted as a result of getting on the wrong side of the FBI in book two of the series, and now spends most of his time drunk and listening to his extensive record collection. That changes when 38 prisoners escape from Maze prison, including Dermott McCain, one of Duffy’s old school mates, now a major IRA operative. MI5 approach Duffy with a proposal that he will be reinstated if he agrees to help them track down McCann. The case is treacherous and the key to getting the information  involves Duffy having to solve a locked room mystery.

This is another masterful effort from McKinty. His grasp of period detail, his smooth assured prose, his ability to impart the social reality and politics of the time, are second to none. It’s even got a cliff hanger of an ending. In the Morning I’ll be Gone is a first class effort.

ThiefJapanese writer Fuminori Nakamura’s The Thief was recommended by of a friend. I also wanted to read Nakamura as he is one of the guests attending Noir Con in Philadelphia this coming October, which I hope to attend, and I wanted to check out his form.

This is a tiny slip of a book, more a large novella than a novel, but it packs a hell of a punch. It is the story of a cynical, seasoned pickpocket. Starting off with a crash course in the how and why he robs whom he does, it moves onto the meat of the story. The pickpocket was once part of a gang of three who worked as a team until a series of events led to the gang splintering. He becomes involved with a young shoplifter and his prostitute mother. Cross cutting with that is the story of a rich powerful man and his ability to manipulate one of his servants.

It is hard to describe the story in further detail without giving too much away. This is really a book you need to read for yourself. It’s one of the most stripped back pieces of noir writing I have read for a while. I loved it.



4 Responses

  1. Nice variety of books. Like you, I loved ‘The Thief’ – a very noir but also very philosophical piece of work. I haven’t read this last book in the McKinty trilogy, but have heard really good things about it. The Chinese book looks interesting – must be a bit of tightrope walking for the author to talk about the criminal justice system in China. Will have to take a look at it.

  2. I haven’t read much for pleasure lately either Andrew but have to agree that IN THE MORNING… is a great read and so good to see a series maintain/improve as it goes along. I’m also thrilled to see THE THIEF get a mention as I really liked it and it seemed not to get much exposure. Sadly I wasn’t nearly so enamoured of Nakamura’s next novel but I’ll still be looking for whatever he does next.

    I’m definitely going to track down the Chinese book – thanks for the tip.

  3. Bernadette and Marina,

    Thanks for stopping by. Interesting that you both like THE THIEF. What do you both think of EVIL AND THE MASK? I have heard very mixed views about it. There is a lot of interesting Japanese crime fiction out there, it’s just a matter of finding time to read it. The next Japanese book I want to read is THE TATTOO MURDER CASE by Akimitsu Takagi.

    Marina, the fact that HANGING DEVILS is set in the nineties and not now is probably a clever way of avoiding problems on the author’s part. As I said, it dragged a little for me but it was still an interesting read.



  4. Thanks for these reviews, Andrew. I am way behind on the McGeachin and McKinty series (as in haven’t even started, but I have book 1 of both). Don’t know if I will try the He Jiahong book, but definitely want to read The Thief.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.