Having lived in Bangkok in the mid-nineties and visited the city many times, I can only concur with Christopher G Moore that the new anthology he has edited, Bangkok Noir, is overdue.
I’ve long lamented to anyone who’ll listen that writers do not make more of Asia as a setting for crime fiction. Thailand is no exception. Things happen there every day, fantastic and awful that you simply could not make up if you tried.
Of the many noir anthologies to hit the shelves in recent years, only one other is set in Asia, Dehli Noir. To add to the allure of Bangkok Noir, two of the 12 stories are by Thai authors, although women don’t figure at all which is a bizarre omission.
The major question I have in relation to the anthology is whether it’s actually noir.
There’s a time to get picky about the definition of ‘noir’. I reckon when someone includes the word in the title of their book and there’s every indication that book will be the first of a series, that time is now.
Moore deals with the question of what is noir in the preface to the anthology and in a post he wrote here in late March for the website International Crime Authors Reality Check.
Moore, whose fictional Bangkok-based PI Vincent Calvino recently had his 12th literary outing, knows more than to take as his starting point the now mainstream conception of noir fiction and film, crime stories that happen at night and involves disillusioned private detectives lurking in shadows.
Instead he chooses to focus on what noir means when set outside the West.
What does it mean for noir fiction when it is set in a place where corruption and extreme violence are regular features of everyday life and the term ‘criminal’ is often simply a label applied by the local elite to anyone who tries to assert their rights? Flowing from this, there’s also what it means when it is the state itself that is the major criminal actor.
Although he doesn’t mention it, Moore could just as easily have tossed in the widespread believe in the supernatural, prevalent throughout much of Asia as another unique feature that needs to be factored into noir writing set outside the West.
These are all interesting, thoughtful questions. But it’s Moore’s claim, if I’m reading him correctly, that he’s trying to pioneer a new form of noir, that I’m not sure stands up to scrutiny.
As he puts it, “The challenge of New Noir is for readers to imagine criminals as victims but the kind of victim that refuses to submit to dictatorship but goes down fighting.”
Going back to the US pulp writers of the thirties and forties, noir fiction has always focused on crimes of desire committed by people hemmed in by social and political conditions. Many of those writers, Goodis, Thompson, Brewer, and many of those that followed, sided with the down and out, those who are trapped and take hopeless actions to escape that trap, which ultimately fail.
There are certainly echoes of this tradition in Bangkok Noir, as there are in elements of Thai society: the ability of the powerful to act with impunity, the way members of the elite can be trapped by rigid cultural expectations in much the same way as the poor are trapped by economic structures.
It’s just that there’s not enough to justify using the term ‘noir’ in the title.
While all the 12 stories in Bangkok Noir are interesting, too many do not come close to being noir. That said there are some real gems.
‘Halfhead’ by Colin Cotterill is a down right nasty little tale of a bogus psychic employed by the local police to help them solve crime, and his relationship with his malevolent spirit guide.
For my money, Cotterill’s yarn comes the closest to pulling off a uniquely Thai take on noir, although ‘Gone East’ by John Burdett (known for his series of novels featuring the half-Thai cop Sonchai Jitpleecheep), which covers some similar ground, is also good.
The most classic ‘noir’ story is perhaps American crime writer Timothy Hallinan’s ‘Hansum Man’. This deals with a Vietnam vet once considered a ‘hansum man’ by the local bar girls, who comes back to Bangkok after many years away to find that a lot has changed, if indeed it was ever really the way he though it was.
Thai writer Tew Bunnag’s ‘The Mistress Wants Her Freedom’ is an interesting take on the plight of a mia noi, or mistress, who plots to get out of her cloistered and incredibly boring relationship with a very wealthy and powerful industrialist.
Another highlight, Dean Barrett’s ‘Death of a Legend’ is a gritty story of an aging Thai hitman whose assignment to eliminate a famous rival takes an unexpected twist.
Moore is to be applauded for having the drive to start something interesting with lots of potential. Hopefully, if there are to be subsequent volumes in the series, they will live up to the noir heritage he is eager to be a part of.
Bangkok Noir is available from Heaven Lake Press
Photo courtesy of German photographer Ralf Tooten, from his exhibition Bangkok Noir, held at the Goethe-Institut Bangkok in January this year.
Great review Andrew. I also thought Colin Cotterill came closest to pulling off a truly Thai kind of noir, with Dean Barrett a close runner-up. I also appreciated the insight gained from having access to crime stories by Thai writers. Here’s to more such anthologies – all the better if future collections include women writers.
I have yet to read “Bangkok Noire” although I have now put it on my “to read” list.
I agree with you, – it is strange that fiction writers do not make more use of Asia as a setting for crime fiction. Asia, not just S.E. Asia has perhaps an over-abundance of possibilities with weird and wild things constantly happening.
Perhaps part of the problem is that readers may not accept that such goings-on are possible? Having seen how many “civilized” westerners behave when they hit the bars of Asia, I can well see that many of them believe they have discovered an entirely new world.
Asia has much to offer, besides the bars and the naked girls, of course. The possibilities for plots and stories are endless, whether it be radicals, slave-traders, drug runners, porn suppliers or just honest-to-goodness crooks.
My latest book is called “Come here and I’ll Show You” and involves skullduggery in Thailand, Cambodia and Laos. All of the locations are accurately described and all of the key characters are based on people that I know. The sequel is to be based around events in Southern Philippines and will follow a similar pattern to the previous book.
As you correctly point out, Asia has a wealth of resources for any crime writer; a writer does not have to look very far to find the low-life.
I like the new look for your Blog, – very refreshing!
Best wishes, Derek Lantin. http://dereklantin.booksabuzz.com
Thanks for stopping by. Apologies for the tardy response, but your very interesting comment got caught in my spam filter. I totally agree with you on all counts. Glad you like the look of the new blog.